diff --git a/plugin/fugitive.vim b/plugin/fugitive.vim
index 7232066..b60f206 100644
--- a/plugin/fugitive.vim
+++ b/plugin/fugitive.vim
@@ -1007,9 +1007,10 @@ function! s:Commit(args, ...) abort
       let error = get(errors,-2,get(errors,-1,'!'))
       if error =~# 'false''\=\.$'
         let args = a:args
-        let args = s:gsub(args,'%(%(^| )-- )@<!%(^| )@<=%(-[esp]|--edit|--interactive|patch|--signoff)%($| )','')
+        let args = s:gsub(args,'%(%(^| )-- )@<!%(^| )@<=%(-[esp]|--edit|--interactive|--patch|--signoff)%($| )','')
         let args = s:gsub(args,'%(%(^| )-- )@<!%(^| )@<=%(-c|--reedit-message|--reuse-message|-F|--file|-m|--message)%(\s+|\=)%(''[^'']*''|"%(\\.|[^"])*"|\\.|\S)*','')
         let args = s:gsub(args,'%(^| )@<=[%#]%(:\w)*','\=expand(submatch(0))')
+        let args = s:sub(args, '\ze -- |$', ' --no-edit --no-interactive --no-signoff')
         let args = '-F '.s:shellesc(msgfile).' '.args
         if args !~# '\%(^\| \)--cleanup\>'
           let args = '--cleanup=strip '.args